,

3 Takeaways from JMU Football’s Ugly Loss to UConn

JMU football lost to UConn on Saturday, 46-22. It ties the Dukes’ largest defeat of the FBS era (2022 vs. Louisville).

It was a rough showing for JMU, which drops to 8-3 overall. The Dukes have a bye week this coming week before the regular-season finale against Coastal Carolina. JMU is still in contention to win the Sun Belt East, despite Saturday’s horrendous nonconference showing.

Here are three takeaways from the loss.

Billy Napier questions

Let’s start with an obvious point: JMU is not going to fire Billy Napier after one season, especially one that’s guaranteed to finish with a winning record. He will not be fired, nor should he be.

But the last two games (possibly three) of this season will be important for his perception among fans, and he’s going to enter Year 2 with a lot of pressure to prove his Florida tenure won’t define the rest of his head coaching career. As JMU moves into the American Conference, the competition will only get better.

My major question about Napier is why can’t he get the discipline issue fixed? The clock management against App State and Troy was questionable, and I have concerns about that moving forward. But most astounding is JMU’s discipline issue.

JMU committed 13 penalties against UConn, including several terrible ones. An unsportsmanlike conduct penalty after a third-down sack kept a UConn drive alive, and UConn went on to score a touchdown to blow the game open, taking a 26-13 lead. That can’t happen.

It’s on Napier to avoid those silly penalties. Florida fans were furious at the end of his tenure over sloppy play and consistently awful penalties. Those have come with him to Harrisonburg.

Bob Chesney always preached: team, teammate, self. Essentially, put the team and your teammates above yourself. Getting an unsportsmanlike conduct penalty after a sack that you didn’t even get? That’s about as selfish as it gets.

Napier needs to get those issues cleaned up fast because it’s really hard to win games with 13 penalties for 130 yards. That lack of discipline starts with the coaching staff.

Excuses or reasons why?

Football teams and coaches are judged by results, but some results deserve context.

JMU just played its 11th consecutive game without a bye week. That’s a daunting task both physically and mentally. It’s more than possible that JMU players were drained and weren’t fired up for a road nonconference game in mid-November.

The Dukes played without safety Jayon Harvey, who is perhaps the team’s best defensive player. They were also without running back George Pettaway, who is perhaps the team’s best offensive player.

Those all come across as lame excuses after a blowout loss, but they might just be reasons why JMU is fading late in the season. It’s no coincidence that JMU’s running game has slowed down after the conference’s leading rusher went down with an injury late against App State. The defense has had issues all season, but Harvey was among the most reliable players in the secondary. Without him, the unit is a complete liability.

Two absences and no bye week don’t completely excuse JMU’s performance on Saturday, but they help explain it. This JMU team, with dozens of new players, seems to have lackluster depth after Bob Chesney’s departure gutted the roster. Chesney’s 2024 team had iffy depth, too. He built it up in 2025 and made the College Football Playoff.

Napier might not take the Dukes back to the CFP in 2027, but he deserves some grace to build depth. It is really hard to be a Group of Six team with major coaching and roster turnover. Next year should be easier, at least from a roster management perspective. 

Now what?

JMU only has one regular-season game left, and that’s on Nov. 28 against Coastal Carolina. A win and a Georgia Southern loss in one of its final two games sends JMU to the Sun Belt title game against Louisiana Tech.

Yes, somehow, this team could still win a league title. I don’t see it happening, but it’s technically possible.

The Dukes still have plenty to play for, and a win over Coastal Carolina and another victory in a bowl game would give JMU a 10-win season. That’s meaningful, too.

Looking ahead, however, this offseason feels massive. JMU will likely join the American Conference next fall. Even if the Dukes are in the Sun Belt for one more year, how will Napier and company handle the roster?

Does JMU want JC Evans or Camden Coleman as the starting quarterback next year? Both have had great moments, but they’ve also floundered in recent games.

How do the coaches feel about the defense? It’s possible JMU blows up much of its defense, trying to go into the portal to find more consistent and productive defensive linemen and defensive backs. The lack of consistent pass rush when rushing four linemen is among the biggest reasons the Dukes have three losses in the last four games.

Offensively, JMU will have to replace both George Pettaway and Seth Cromwell. The Dukes will have to look for a proven portal running back. And what about its receivers? Can they retain players like Corey Scott and Michael Scott or will that position group need a major reloading, too?

JMU has a few games left this season, but the personnel department has a busy couple of months ahead. If the Dukes want to return to CFP contention, they need to build up the roster in a couple of key spots. Issues along the defensive front and secondary were glaring Saturday, and they can’t be fixed entirely with player development.

The Dukes need outside help.

Photo courtesy of JMU Athletics Communications

YouTube player

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Subscribe To The Podcast
Subscribe to the JMU Sports News Podcast Feed wherever you find your podcasts. Fresh episodes hitting your feed every few days during the JMU Sports Season.
Mondays: To The House with Delvin Joyce
Wednesdays: JMU Sports News Podcast with Bennett & Jack

Part of the BLEAV Podcast Network.


Youtube

YouTube player